A novel smartphone App to support the clinical practice of pediatric ophthalmology and strabismus: the validation of visual acuity tests.

This study is aimed at describing the TreC Oculistica novel smartphone App that facilitated the clinical practice of pediatric ophthalmology and strabismus during the COVID-19 pandemic and at reporting on the validation of visual acuity tests in a home setting. The Trec Oculistica smartphone App was prescribed to eligible patients at the Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus Clinic, Ophthalmology Unit of Rovereto Hospital, between September 2020 and March 2022. Four key indicators were identified for monitoring visual and visuo-motor functions remotely: visual acuity, ocular motility, head posture, and color vision. Clinicians selected few mobile applications (iOS, Android) and printable materials within the Trec Oculistica App: the Snellen Chart Visual Acuity App, the 9Gaze App, the eyeTilt App, the Color Blind test App, the LEA Symbols pdf, and the Snellen Chart pdf. All patients, aged 4 and older, were screened at home for visual acuity at 3 m and later in the clinic (LEA Symbols cabinet or Snellen computerized optotype). The 9Gaze, the eyeTilt, and the Color Blind test Apps were only recommended to a subset of patients based on clinical suspicion or diagnosis. The Wilcoxon signed rank sum test and weighted Cohen's kappa coefficient were applied to compare pairs of scores from different settings. The Trec Oculistica App was downloaded and activated by 97 patients or their caregiver. 40 patients were tested at home using the 9Gaze App, 7 used the eyeTilt App, and 11 used the Color-Blind test App. Families reported that all the Apps were easy and intuitive to use; clinicians reported that measurements were reliable. 82 eyes of 41 patients (mean age 5.2 years, SD ± 0.4, range 4.4-6.1) were tested for visual acuity using the self-administered LEA Symbols pdf. 92 eyes of 46 patients (mean age 11.6 years, SD ± 5.2, range 6-35) were evaluated using the self-administered Snellen Chart Visual Acuity App or the Snellen Chart pdf. Home median visual acuity score was statistically different from that registered in clinical setting for both the LEA Symbols pdf (P-value = 0.0074) and the Snellen Chart App and pdf (P-value = 0.0001). The strength of agreement was 0.12 (slight) for the LEA Symbols pdf, 0.50 (moderate) for the Snellen Chart Visual Acuity App, and 0.69 (substantial) for the Snellen Chart pdf. CONCLUSION: The novel TreC Oculistica smartphone App was a useful tool for facilitating the clinical practice of pediatric ophthalmology and strabismus during the COVID-19 pandemic. In the follow-up of strabismus patients and patients with suspected inherited retinal diseases, the 9Gaze, eyeTilt, and Color Blind test applications were deemed to be intuitive and easy to use by families and were considered reliable by clinicians. In a home setting, visual acuity tested by means of Snellen Charts was moderately congruent with the in-office examination. On the contrary, agreement was poor in younger children tested with the LEA Symbols pdf. WHAT IS KNOWN: • Teleophthalmology enables clinicians to evaluate patients' ocular diseases remotely and various tools are helpful for screening, follow-ups and treatment. • Smartphones can currently be used to obtain ocular images and vision measurements of patients' eyes and this information can be shared with the ophthalmologist for further evaluations and medical management (mhealth). WHAT IS NEW: • Smartphone Apps can be successfully used in a hybrid teleophthalmology service concerning first visits and follow-ups. • Apps and printable materials are easy, intuitive to use for patients and  also reliable for  clinicians.

Early childhood eye diseases and perinatal risk factors: potential of record linkage between current information flows.

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to analyze the occurrence of specific maternal, obstetric or neonatal factors, by performing a comparison between children with refractive error, strabismus and/or amblyopia (cases) and unaffected children (controls) in the province of Trento (North-East Italy). METHODS: In 2012-2014, 14,346 children attending the second year of nursery school were assessed through the preschool orthoptic screening scheme (covering 91% of the preschool population). Record linkage was performed between the orthoptic screening database and birth records (birth confirmation certificate database) for the corresponding birth cohorts (2008-2010), to examine specific maternal factors (age, smoking, nationality/race), obstetric factors (type of delivery) and neonatal factors (gestational age, weight at birth, Apgar Score, congenital birth defects, hospitalization at birth). The correlations were investigated using univariate and multivariate analysis in accordance with the logistic regression method. RESULTS: During orthoptic screening, 6.4% of children were found to have at least one refractive error, with astigmatism being the most common condition (5.1%). 1.9% of children were found to have strabismus and 1.8% amblyopia. Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that the risk of developing a refractive error is associated with: maternal age ≥45 years, foreign nationality, vacuum-assisted delivery and neonatal weight <1500 grams. An excessive risk of strabismus was observed in children whose mother had smoked during pregnancy (adjusted OR=1.64). CONCLUSIONS: Preschool orthoptic screening is a well-consolidated practice in the province of Trento, with adhesion values consistently over 90%. Studies of this type show the potential of record linkage between current information flows.

Implementation of tele visit healthcare services triggered by the COVID-19 emergency: the Trentino Province experience.

AIM: In response to the SARS-CoV-2 emergency, the Competence Centre on digital health 'TrentinoSalute4.0' has developed TreC_Televisita, a tele visit solution that meets the needs of the Trentino healthcare system and maintains high-quality patient-doctor interactions while respecting social distancing. This paper highlights how 'TreC_Televisita' was integrated into the Trentino healthcare system and its potential to become a structural and durable solution for the future local healthcare service provisioning. SUBJECT AND METHODS: This paper presents the multifactorial context that TreC_Televisita has faced for its implementation and the strategies adopted for its structural integration into the healthcare system. The analysis focuses on the main issues faced for the integration of the tele visits (e.g. privacy, payments) and how the context of TrentinoSalute4.0 permitted responding quickly to its implementation during the pandemic. It also describes how TreC_Televisita fits into the healthcare continuum from the organisational and technological standpoint, the end-user perspective and the barriers that could hamper the solution scalability. RESULTS: TreC_Televisita has demonstrated to be a technological solution that can be contextualised for different clinical domains beyond SARS-CoV-2. Moreover, it has shown its potential to scale up the solution beyond the COVID-19 emergency to the whole healthcare provisioning system in the long term. CONCLUSION: Being a positive experience in the first months of its implementation, the long-term goal is to transform TreC_Televisita into a structural pillar of the Trentino healthcare system, setting the bases for a sustainable, win-win situation for all the stakeholders involved in healthcare service provisioning.

Enabling teleophthalmology during the COVID-19 pandemic in the Province of Trento, Italy: Design and implementation of a mHealth solution.

BACKGROUND: Due to the many restrictions imposed during the COVID-19 emergency, the normal clinical activities have been stopped abruptly in view of limiting the circulation of the virus. The extraordinary containment measures have had a dramatic impact on the undertaking and follow-up of ophthalmic outpatients. OBJECTIVE: In order to guarantee proper monitoring and routine care, the Pediatric Ophthalmology equipe of Rovereto Hospital (North-East of Italy) supported by the Competence Center on Digital Health TrentinoSalute4.0, designed and implemented a digital platform, TreC Oculistica, enabling teleophthalmology. We report our innovative-albeit restricted-experience aiming at testing and maximizing the efficacy of remote ophthalmic and orthoptic visits. METHODS: A multidisciplinary team created the TreC Oculistica platform and defined a teleophthalmology protocol. The system consists of a clinician web interface and a patient mobile application. Clinicians can prescribe outpatients with the App and some preliminary measurements to be self-collected before the televisit. The App conveys the clinician's requests (i.e. measurements) and eases the share of the collected information in a secure digital environment, promoting a new health care workflow. RESULTS: Four clinicians took part in the testing phase (2 ophthalmologists and 2 orthoptists) and recruited 37 patients (mostly pediatric) in 3 months. Thanks to a continuous feedback between the testing and the technical implementation, it has been possible to identify pros and cons of the implemented functionalities, considering possible improvements. Digital solutions such as TreC Oculistica advance the digitalization of the Italian health care system, promoting a structured and effective reorganization of the workload supported by digital systems. CONCLUSIONS: The study tested an innovative digital solution in the teleophthalmology context and represented the first experience within the Italian healthcare system. This solution opens up new possibilities and scenarios that can be effective not only during the pandemic, but also in the traditional management of public health services.

Validation of the 2WIN Corneal Reflexes App in children.

PURPOSE: To test the reliability and accuracy of the 2Win Refractometer Corneal Reflexes App (CR App) in detecting manifest strabismus in pediatric patients. METHODS: Prospective study involving 167 children with suspected strabismus (mean age 7.6 years; SD = 3.0, range 2-14 years) undergoing the CR App ocular alignment assessment (Pediatric Ophthalmologist) versus the alternate cover test with prism ocular alignment assessment for distance (Orthoptist) as the gold standard. The AAPOS 2013 guidelines for the detection of manifest strabismus in primary position (> 8 PD) were used. RESULTS: Total sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV for the CR App were 79.2%, 86.2%, 86.4%, and 78.9%, respectively. The overall inconclusive rate was 17.9%, but was 36.3% in children younger than 5. Sensitivity and PPV for vertical deviations were poor (33.3% and 12.5%, respectively). The accuracy of the CR App regarding the degree (in prism diopters) of manifest deviations was tested with the Wilcoxon signed rank sum test: correlation with the gold standard was good for esodeviations (p value = 0.765, not statistically significant) and poorer for exodeviations (p value = 0.056, still not statistically significant), whereas a significant difference (p value = 0.0001) was observed for vertical deviations. CONCLUSION: The CR App showed good sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV for manifest strabismus > 8PD in accordance with the AAPOS 2013 guidelines; sensitivity and PPV were poor for vertical deviations. The accuracy of the CR App was good for horizontal deviations, but poor for vertical deviations. The inconclusive result rate was high in younger children.

Comparison of 2Win and plusoptiX A12R refractometers with Retinomax handheld autorefractor keratometer.

PURPOSE: To test the accuracy and validity of the 2Win and the plusoptiX A12R refractometers in detecting amblyopia risk factors. METHODS: Children were screened using both devices, using two sets of referral criteria each, and underwent complete ophthalmic examination, including cycloplegic refraction. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were calculated. Median values for the pairs of refractometers were compared using the Wilcoxon signed-rank sum test for sphere, cylinder, and power vectors J0 and J45 for axis (both eyes). RESULTS: A total of 284 eyes of 142 children (mean age, 37.9 ± 19.8 months) were included. Comparison of mean cycloplegic and manifest refractometer measurements provided statistically significant differences in both eyes. For sphere, the means were lower and for cylinder, higher for both devices, and both correlated well with the gold standard for astigmatic power vectors J0 and J45. Using referral criteria 1, the sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV, and inconclusive results were 67.4%, 83.7%, 87.9%, 59.4%, and 4.9%, respectively, for the 2Win, with sensitivity of 13% in the hyperopia group; 73.1%, 95.9%, 96.6%, 69.1%, and 10.6%, respectively, for the plusoptiX A12R, with a sensitivity of 33.3% in the hyperopia group. Using criteria 2, the values were 98.8%, 38.8%, 73.9%, and 95.0% (2Win) and 94.9%, 65.3%, 81.3%, and 88.9% (plusoptiX A12R). CONCLUSIONS: In manifest conditions, the accuracy of the 2Win and plusoptiX A12R refractometers is low in hyperopia and astigmatism, but the devices are well correlated with each other, and both have high specificity; sensitivity is low in hyperopia, resulting in the underestimation of hyperopic refractive error. The optional Plusoptix sensitive referral criteria seems to be appropriate for the A12R. The 2Win provided fewer inconclusive results and was preferred for use with younger and developmentally delayed children.